Date            Type of         Proceeding
Issued          Case (1)        or App'n No.            Party/Parties

9-7             OPP             106,932                 PRL USA
                OPP             110,254                 Holdings,
                                                        Inc. v. Malibu
                                                        Riding and Tennis
                                                        Club, Ltd.


                                Opposer's/              Applicant's/
                                Petitioner's            Respondent's
                TTAB            Mark and                Mark and
Issue           Decision        Goods/Services          Goods/Services

2(d)            Opposition      "POLO BY                two marks that,
                Sustained       RALPH LAUREN"           while differing
                in both         (and design)            in some design
                cases           [men's suits,           features, both
                                slacks, ties,           comprise the
                                sweaters, shoes,        words "MALIBU
                                shirts, hats,           POLO CLUB" and a
                                belts, socks; and       representation of
                                ladies' blouses,        a polo player
                                skirts, suits,          [one mark
                                and dresses];           for clothing,
                                "THE POLO CLUB"         headgear, and
                                [retail clothing        footwear, namely,
                                store services];        athletic shoes,
                                "POLO"                  bathrobes, boxer
                                [for clothing           shorts, briefs,
                                and accessories         clothing caps,
                                similar to those        rain coats, over
                                listed above; and       coats, polo
                                for providing           shirts, jackets,
                                information in the      parkas, ponchos,
                                field of fashion,       sports shirts,
                                fragrance, life-        sweat shirts,
                                style and other         t-shirts, under
                                topics of general       shorts, Bermuda
                                interest by             shorts, gym
                                means of a global       shorts, sweat
                                computer network];      shorts, socks, gym
                                "POLO RALPH             suits, jogging
                                LAUREN"                 suits, sweat
                                (and design             suits, warm-up
                                incorporating           suits and athletic
                                a polo player)          uniforms; the
                                [for men's and          other mark for
                                women's wearing         clothing,
                                apparel and             headgear, and
                                accessories             footwear, namely,
                                similar to those        shoes, socks,
                                listed above];          shorts, pants,
                                two marks that,         shirts, jackets,
                                while differing         and hats;
                                slightly in             dissemination of
                                design consist of       advertising
                                the representation      matter; goods of
                                of a polo player        precious metals
                                [one mark for           and their alloys,
                                clothing and            namely, jewelry,
                                accessories             clocks, watches
                                similar to those        and watch bands,
                                listed above; the       and chronographs]
                                other mark for
                                jewelry and for
                                the information
                                services listed
                                above]


Marks and                                       Citable as
Goods Cited by                                  Precedent
Examining Atty.                                 of TTAB

                                                No


(1)EX=EX PARTE APPEAL; OPP=OPPOSITION; CANC=CANCELLATION; CU=CONCURRENT
USE; (SJ)=SUMMARY JUDGMENT; (R)=REQ. FOR RECONSIDERATION; (MD)=MOTION
TO DISMISS; (MR)=MOTION TO REOPEN