United States Patent and Trademark Office OG Notices: 30 December 2003
Notice Concerning European Patent Office Competence to Act as a Patent Cooperation Treaty Authority The European Patent Office (EPO) has notified the International Bureau of the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) that the EPO will resume its competence to act as both an International Searching Authority and an International Preliminary Examining Authority for applications relating to the fields of biotechnology and telecommunications filed by applicants who are U.S. residents or nationals. However, the EPO will continue not to be a competent International Searching Authority and an International Preliminary Examining Authority for business methods applications. For the definition of what the EPO considers to be precluded subject matter in the field of business methods, applicants should see the "Notice from the President of the European Patent Office" dated 26 November 2001, and which is attached to this Notice as Annex A. The text of the letter is attached to this Notice as Annex B. The EPO will resume acting as a competent International Searching Authority (ISA), within the meaning of PCT Article 16(3), for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals on or after 01 January 2004 in the USPTO or International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office, and where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of biotechnology. However, the EPO will not be a competent ISA for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals in the USPTO or International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office on or after 01 March 2002 and before 01 January 2004, where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of biotechnology. See Notice Concerning EPO Competence to Act as PCT Authority, 1255 Off. Gaz. Pat. Office 878 (Feb. 19, 2002). Furthermore, the EPO will continue not to be a ISA, within the meaning of PCT Article 16(3), for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals on or after 01 March 2002 in the USPTO or International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office, and where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of business methods. The EPO will resume acting as a competent International Preliminary Examining Authority (IPEA), within the meaning of PCT Article 32(3), for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals on or after 01 January 2004 in the USPTO or IB as receiving Office, where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of biotechnology and where the EPO acted as the ISA. However, the EPO will not be a competent IPEA for international applications filed before 01 January 2004 by U.S. residents or nationals in the USPTO or International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office where the corresponding demand was filed with the EPO on or after 01 March 2002, where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of biotechnology. As of 01 July 2004, the EPO will resume acting as a competent IPEA, within the meaning of PCT Article 32(3), for demands filed by U.S. residents or nationals on or after 01 July 2004 for international applications filed in the USPTO or IB as receiving Office, where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of telecommunication and where the EPO acted as the ISA. However, the EPO will not be a competent IPEA for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals in the USPTO or International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office where the corresponding demand was filed with the EPO on or after 01 March 2002 and before 01 July 2004, where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of telecommunications. The EPO will continue not to be a competent IPEA, within the meaning of PCT Article 32(3), for international applications filed by U.S. residents or nationals in the USPTO or IB as receiving Office where the corresponding demand is filed with the EPO on or after 01 March 2002, and where the application contains one or more claims directed to the field of business methods. This limitation applies to all demands received at the EPO on or after 01 March 2002 including demands in applications that were filed before 01 March 2002 for which the EPO was still the competent ISA. Residents or nationals of the U.S. should not select the EPO as the ISA/IPEA when filing applications in the field of business methods nor select the EPO as the IPEA prior to 01 July 2004 when filing a demand in an international application in the field of telecommunications. The classification of an international application is a function of the ISA (PCT Rule 43.3(b)), and as such, the United States Receiving Office (RO/US) has neither the resources nor the authority to determine if applications fall within the above International Patent Classification Units. Therefore, the RO/US will rely solely on applicant determinations as to the area of classification and the resulting competency of the EPO, and as such, the RO/US will forward to the EPO all applications in which the EPO is indicated as the ISA/IPEA in our normal course of doing business. STEPHEN G. KUNIN Deputy Commissioner for Patent Examination Policy Annex A Notice from the President of the European Patent Office dated 26 November 2001 concerning limitation of the EPO's competence as a PCT authority Limitation criteria 1. Pursuant to Article 3(4)(a)(ii) of the PCT Agreement between the European Patent Organization and the International Bureau of the World Intellectual Property Organization, as amended with effect from 1 November 2001 (OJ EPO 2001,601), the European Patent Office (EPO) will not carry out (a) international search in respect of any international application filed on or after 1 March 2002 by a national or resident of the United States of America with the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) or the International Bureau (IB) as receiving Office where such application contains one or more claims relating to the fields of biotechnology or business methods, as defined by the International Patent Classification units indicated below in paragraphs 3 and 4. (b) international preliminary examination in respect of any international application filed by a national or resident of the United States of America with the USPTO or the IB as receiving Office where the corresponding demand is filed with the EPO on or after 1 March 2002 and the application contains one or more claims relating to the fields of biotechnology or business methods as referred to in sub-paragraph (a) above or to the field of telecommunication as defined by the International Patent Classification unit indicated below in paragraph 5. 2. Without prejudice to the right of the EPO to issue any further notice under Article 3(4) of the PCT Agreement which it may consider necessary, the initial duration of these limitations will be three years (Article 3(4)(c) of the PCT Agreement). International Patent Classification 3. Biotechnology C12M Apparatus for enzymology or microbiology C12N Micro-organisms or enzymes; compositions thereof C12P Fermentation or enzyme-using processes to synthesise a desired chemical compound or composition or to separate optical isomers from a racemic mixture C12Q Measuring or testing processes involving enzymes or micro-organisms; compositions or test papers therefor; processes of preparing such compositions; condition- responsive control in microbiological or enzymological processes C07K Peptides G01N33/50 (including subdivisions) Chemical analysis of biological material, e.g. blood, urine; testing involving biospecific ligand binding methods; immunological testing A61K39 Medicinal preparations containing antigens or antibodies A61K48 Medicinal preparations containing genetic material which is inserted into cells of the living body to treat genetic diseases; gene therapy A01H New plants or processes for obtaining them; plant reproduction by tissue culture techniques For information: U.S. classes covering corresponding subject-matter 424 Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions 435 Chemistry: molecular biology and microbiology 436 Chemistry: analytical and immunological testing 514 Drug, bio-affecting and body treating compositions 530 Chemistry: natural resins or derivatives; peptides or proteins; lignins or reaction products thereof 536 Organic compounds-part of the class 532-570 series 800 Multicellular living organisms and unmodified parts thereof 930 Peptide or protein sequence 4. Business method related inventions GO6F17/60 Digital computing or data processing equipment or methods, specially adapted for specific functions: administrative, commercial, managerial, supervisory or forecasting purposes. If an application falls within this subgroup but does not relate to business methods, the EPO's competence is not affected. For information: U.S. class covering corresponding subject-matter 705 Data processing: financial, business practice, management, or cost/price determination 5. Telecommunication H04 Electric communication technique with the exception of H04N: pictorial communication, e.g. television For information: U.S. classes covering corresponding subject-matter 370 Multiplex communications 375 Pulse or digital communications 379 Telephonic communication 380 Cryptography 381 Electrical audio signal processing systems and devices 455 Telecommunications Notes 6. The EPO is no longer the competent authority within the meaning of Article 16(3)(b)1 and Article 32(3)2 PCT for applications meeting the criteria defined in paragraph 1. 7. Paragraph 1 also applies to applications filed with the IB rather than the USPTO by two or more applicants, - at least one of whom is a national or resident of the USA, and - none of whom are nationals or residents of an EPC contracting state. 8. It is not possible to reassign competence to the EPO by changing the applicant after the application has been filed with the USPTO or the IB. 9. The limitation criteria in paragraph 1(b) apply to all demands for international preliminary examination received at the EPO on or after 1 March 2002 (sic), which means they are also applicable to applications filed before 1 March 2002 for which the EPO was still the competent International Searching Authority. 1 The receiving Office deletes the indication of any non-competent International Searching Authority ex officio (Receiving Office Guidelines, No. 115, PCT Gazette - IV, 29 of 17 September 1998). 2 Demands for international preliminary examination submitted to a non-competent authority are subject to Rule 59.3 PCT. Annex B Mr. James E. Rogan Director of the United States Patent and Trademark Office US Department of Commerce Box 4 WASHINGTON, D.C. 20231 U.S.A. BY FAX: +1-703 305 8664 Zeichen/Reference/Reference 57.8.10/11 Datum/Date/Date 31.10.2003 Dear Mr Rogan, I refer to the notice dated 26 November 2001 issued pursuant to Article 3(4)(aii) of the Agreement between the EPO and WIPO under the POT (OJ EPO 1/2002, 52, copy enclosed) and now wish to advise you that paragraphs 1(a) and (b) of that notice are to be amended as follows: The reference to the field of biotechnology is deleted from paragraphs 1(a) and (b) with effect for all international applications filed from 1 January 2004 and the reference to the field of telecommunication is deleted from paragraph 1(b) with effect for all demands filed as from 1 July 2004. The effect of these changes is that the EPO will resume its competence as International Seaching Authority and International Preliminary Examining Authority for international applications filed as from 1 January 2004 by nationals or residents of the United States of America where such applications contain one or more claims relating to the field biotechnology as defined by the International Patent Classification Unit indicated in paragraphs 3 and 4 of the notice. The EPO wifl also resume its competence as as lnternational Preliminary Examining Authority in respect of international applications filed by nationals or residents of the United States of America containing one or more claims relating to the field of telecommunications as defined by the International Patent Classification Unit indicated in paragraph 5 of the notice where the corresponding demand is filed on or after 1 July 2004. The reference to the field of business methods in both paragraphs 1(a) and (b) remains intact and the EPO is not competent to act as International Searching Authority or International Preliminary Examining Authority in respect of such applications for the remainder of the term specified in paragraph 2 of the notice. In all other respects the notice remains in full force and effect. I have today written in similar terms to Dr. Idris, Director General of WIPO, requesting that this information be disseminated via the usual WIPO channels. I would ask that you undertake the appropriate steps to bring this information to the attention of US applicants. This information will also be published in the Official Journal of the EPO. Yours sincerely, Dr h.c. Ingo Kober President INTERNATIONAL VERTRAGE INTERNATIONAL TREATIES TRAITES INTERNATIONAUX PCT PCT PCT Mitteilung des Prasi- Notice from the Communique du Presi- denten des Europaischen President of the dente del'Office euro- Patentmts vom 26. No- European Patent Office peaen des brevets, en vember 2001 ubar die dated 26 November date du 26 novembre Beschrankung der Zus- 2001 concerning limi- 2001, relatif Ala tandigkeit des Euro- tation of the EPO's limitation de la paischen Patentamts als competence as a PCT competence de l'Office PCT-Behorde authority europeen des brevets agissant en qualite d'administration au titre du PCT Beschrankungskriterien Limitation criteria Criteres de limitation 1. Nach Artikel 3(4)ii) 1. Pursuant to Article 1. Conformement a der mit Wirkung vom 1. 3(4)(ii) of the PCT l'article 3, paragraphe November 2001 (ABI.EPA Agreement bewtween the (4)a)ii) de l'accord 2001, 601) geanderten European Patent Organi- entre l'Organisation PCT-Vereinbarung sation and the Interna- europeene des brevets zwischen der Europai- tional Bureau of the et le Bureau interna- schen Patentorganisa- World Intellectual tional de l'Organisa- tion und dem Interna- Property Organization, tion Mondiale de la tionalen Buro der as amended with effect Propriete Intellectu- Weltorganisation fur from 1 November 2001 elle au titre du PCT, geistiges Eigentum (OJ) EPO 2001, 601), tel que modifie avec fuhrt das Europaische the European Patent affet au 1st novembre Patentamt (EPA) nicht Office (EPO) will not 2003 (JO OEB, 2001, durch carry out 601), l'Office europeen des brevets (OEB) n'effectuera pas a) die internationale (a) international a) la recherche inter- Recherche fur eine search in respect of nationale a l'egard de internationale Anmel- die any international toute demande interna- dung, am oder nach dem application filed on or tionale deposee aupres 1. Marz 2002 von dinem after 1 March 2002 by a del'Office des brevets Staatsangehorigen Verei national or resident of et des marques de nigten Staaten von the United States of Etats-Unis (USPTO) ou Amerika oder einem America with the United du Bureau international Anmelder, der dort States Patent and (BI) en qualite seinen Sitz oder Trademark Office d'office recapteur a Wohnsitz hat, bein (USPTO) or the Inter- partir du 1st mars 2002 Patent- und Markenamt natinal Bureau (IB) as par une personne de der VereinigtenStaaten receiving Office where nationalite americaine (USPTO) oder beim such application ou residant aux Etats- Internationalen Buro contains one or more Unis d'Amerique, (IB) als Anmeldeamt claims relating to the lorsque la demande de eingereicht wird, wenn fields of biotechnology brevet contient une ou diese Anmeldung einen or business methods, as plusieurs revendica- oder mehrere Anspruche defined by the Interna- tions se rapportant a enthalt, die sich auf tional Patent Classifi- labiotechnologie ou a Biotechnologieoder cation units indicated des methodes commercia- Geschaftsmethoden gemaB below in paragraphs 3 les, telles que der Definition der and 4. definies par les unites Einheiten der Interna- de la Classification tionalen Patentklassi- internationale des fikation in den brevets enumerees aux nachstehenden Absatzen points 3 et 4 ci 3 und 4 beziehen; dessous. b) die internationale (b) international pre- b) l'examen prelimi- vorlaufige Prufung fur liminary examination in naire international a eine internationale respect of any interna- l'egard de toute demand Anmeidung, die von tional application interationale deposee einem Staatsangehorigen filed by a national or aupres de l'USPTO ou du der Vereingten Staaten resident of the United BI en qualite d'office von Amerika oder eniem States of America with recepteur par une Anmelder,der dort th eUSPTO or the IB as personne denationalite seinen Sitz oder receiving Office where americaine ou resi- Wohnsitz hat, beim the corresponding dantaux Etats-Unis USPTO oder beim IB als demand isfiled with the d'Amerique, torsque la Anmeldeamt eingereicht EPO on or after 1 March demande d'examen est wird, wenn der 2002 and the applica- presentee aupres de entsprechende Antrag am tion contains one or l'OEB a partir du 1st oder nacht dem 1. Marz more claims relating 2002 et que la demande 2002 beim EPA to the fields of bio- de brevet contient une eingereicht wird und technology or business ou plusieurs revendica- die Anmeldung einen methods as referred to tions se rapportant a oder mehrere Anspruche in sub-paragraph (a) la biotechnologie ou a enthal, die sich gemaB above or the field of des methodes commer- Buchstabe a auf Biotech- telecommunication as ciales conformement au nologie oder defined by the point a) ci-dessus, Geschaftsmethoden oder International Patent ou au domaine des gemaB der Definition Classification unit telecommunications der Einheit der Inter- indicated below in telque de fini dans nationlen Patentklassi- paragraph 5. l'unite de la Classi- fikation im fication internationale nachstehanden Absatz 5 des brevets indiquee au auf Telekommunikation pointe ci-dessous. beziehen. 2. Die anfangliche 2. Without prejudice to 2. Sans prejudice du Geltungsdauer dieser the right of the EPO to droit de l'OEB Beschrankungen betragt issue any further notice d'emettra toute autre drei Jahre (Artikel 3 under Article 3(4) of notification visee a (4) c) der PCT-Verein- the PCT Agreement which l'article 3(4) de barung); das Recht des it may consider neces- l'accord au titre du EPA, weitere von ihm sary, the initial PCT qu'il juge fur notwendig erachtete duration of these limi- necessaire,la duree Mitteilungen nach tations will be three initials de ces Artikel 3 (4) der PCT- years (Article 3(4)(c) limitations est de Vereinbarung ergahen of the PCT Agreement). trois ans (article zu lassen, bleibt davon 3(4)c) de l'accord au unberuhrt. titre du PCT). Internationale International Classification Patentlkassifikation Patent Classification internationale desbrevets 3. Biotechnologie 3. Biotechnology 3.Biotechnologie C12M Vorrichtungen fur C12M Apparatus for C12M Appareillage pour Enzymologie oder enzymology or micro- l'enzymologie ou la Mikrobiologie giology microbiologie C12N Mikoorganismen C12N Micro-organism or C12N Micro-organismes oder Enzyme; Zusam- enzymes; compositions ou enzymes; composi- mensetzungen aus thereof tions les contenant Mikroorganismen oder C12P Fermentation or C12 Procedes de Enzymen enzyme-using processes fermentation ou C12P Garungsverfahren to synthesise a procedes utilisant des oder Verfahren unter desired chemical enzymes pour la syn- Verwendung von Enzymen compound or composi- these d'un compose zur gezielten tion or to separate chimique donne ou Synthsesvon chemischen optical isomers from d'une composition Verbindungen oder a recemic mixture donnee, ou pour la Zusammensetzungen oder C12Q Measuring or separation d'isomeres zur Trennung optishcer testing processes optiques a partir d'un isomerer aus einer involving enzymes or melange racemique racemischen Mischung microorganism; C12Q Procedes de mesure, C12Q MeB-oder Unter- compositions or test de recherche ou suchungsverfahren papers therefor; d'analyse faisant unter Einbeziehung von processes of preparing intervenir des enzymes Enzymen oder Mikro- such compositions; ou des organismen; condition-responsive microorgansimes; Zusammensetzungen oder control in microbio- composititions ou Testpapiere hierfur, logical or enzymo- papiers reactifs a cet Verfahren zum Herst- logical processes effet; procedes pour ellen derartiger C07K Peptides preparer ces composi- Zusammensetzungen; G01N33/50 (including tions; procedes de Steuern in Abhangig- subdivisions) commande sensiblesaux keit von den Ver- Chemical analysis of conditions du millieu fahrensbedingungen bei biological material, dans les procedes mikrobiologischan oder eg blood, urine; microbiologiques ou enzymologischen testing involving enzymologiques Verfahren biospecific ligand C07K Peptides C07K Peptide binding methods; G01N33/50 G01N33/50 immunological testing (y conpris sous- (einschlieBlich A61K39 Medicinal divisions) Untereinheiten preparations Analyse chimique de Chemische Analyse von containing antigens or materiau biologique, biologischen Stoffen, antibodies p.ex.de sang, d'urine; z. B. Blut, Urin; A61K48 Medicinal recherche ou analyse Untersuchung unter preparations contain- par des methodes Anwendung biospez- ing genetic material faisant intervenir la fischer Liganden- which is inserted into formation de liaisons bindungsverfahren; cells of the living biospecifiques par immunologische Unter- body to treat genetic ligands, recherche ou suchungsverfahren diseases; gene therapy analyse immunologique A61K39 Medizinische A01H New plants or A61K39 Preparations Praparate die Antigene processes for medicinales contenant oder Antikorper obtaining them; plant des antigenes ou des enthalten reproduction by tissue anticorps A61K48 Medizinische culture techniques A61K48 Preparations Zubereitungen, die medicinales contenant genetische Material du material genetique enthalten, das in qui est introduit dans Zellen des lebenden des cellules du corps Korpers eingefuhrt vivant pour traiter wird, um genetisch des maladies geneti- bedingte Krankheiten ques; therapie genique zubehandeln; A01H Nouveautes Gentherapie vegetales ou procedes A01H Neue Pflanzen oder pour leur obtention; Verfahren zu deren reproduction de Gewinnung; Pflanzen- plantes par des tech- reproduction durch niques de culture des Gewebekulturverfahren tissues Zur Information: For information: Pour information: US-Klassen, unter US classes covering classes US die die entsprechenden corresponding couvrant les objects Gegenstande fallen subject-matter correspondants 424 Arzneimittel, 424 Drug, bio-affecting 424 Compositions medic- bioaktive und Korper- and body treating amensteuses, a effet behandlungsmittel composition biologique et pour les 435 Chemie: Molekular- 435 Chemistry: soins du corps biologie und Mikrobi- molecular biology and 435 Chimie: biologie logie microbiology moleculaire et 436 Chemie:analytische 436 Chemistry: microbiologie und immunologische analytical and immuno- 436 Chimie: essals ana- Untersuchungsverfahren logical testing lytiques et analyses 514 Arzneimittel, 514 Drug, bio-affecting immunologiques bioaktive und Korper- and body treating com- 514 Compositions behandlungsmitte positions medicamenteuses, a 530 Chemie: naturliche 530 Chemistry: natural effet biologique et Harze oder deren resins or derivatives; pour les soins du Derivate; Peptide oder peptides or proteins; corps Proteine; Lignine oder lignins or reaction 530 Chimie: resines deren Reaktionspro- products thereof naturelles ou derives; dukte 536 Organic compounds- peptidesou proteines; 536 Organische part of the class lignines ou leurs Verbindugen-Tell der 532-570 series produits de reaction Klassenreihe 532-570 800 Multicellular 536 Composes 800 Mehrellige lebenda living organisms and organiques-partie des Organismen und deren unmodified parts series desclasses unveranderte Teile thereof 532-570 930 Peptid-oder 930 Peptide or protein 800 Organismes vivant Proteinsequenzen sequence multicellulaires et leure parties non modifiees 930 Sequencesde peptides oude proteines 4. Erfindungen 4. Business 4. Inventions betreffend method related relatives a des Geschaftsmethoden inventions methodes commerciales GO6F17/60 Digitale GO6F17/60 Digital GO6F17/60 Equipement Rechen-oder Datenver- computing or data ou methodes de arbeitungsanlagen processing equipment traitment de donnees oder-verfahren, or methods, specially ou de calcul besonders angepaBt an anadapted for specific numerique, speciale- speezielle Anwendungen: functions: administra- ment adaptes a des verwaltungstechnische, tive, commercial,mana- fonctions specifiques: wirtschaftliche, gerial, supervisory or a des fins administra- geschaftliche Zwecke, forecasting purposes. tives, commerciales, Uberwachungs-oder If an application de gestion, de sur- Voraus sagezwecks. falls within this veillance ou de Soweit die Anmeldung subgroup but does not prevision. La com- unter die vorstehend relate to businessn petence de l'OEB genannte Untergruppe methods, the EPO's n'est pas affectee en fallt, sich aber competence is not ce qui concerns les nicht auf Geschafts- affected. demandes relevant de methoden bezieht, ce sous-groupe, mais bleibt die Zustandig- ne se rapportant pas a keit des EPA unberuhrt. des methodes commerciales. Zur Information: For information: Pour information: US-Klasse, unter die US class covering classes US die entsprechenden corresponding couvrant les objects Gegenstande fallen subject-matter correspondants 705 Datenverabeitung: 705 Data processing: 705 Traitement de Finanz-, Geschafts- financial, business donnees: gestion des prazxis, Management practice management, comptes, pratiques oder Kosten- or cost/price commerciales, gestion Preisermittlung determination ou etablissement des couts et des prix 5. Telekommunikation 5. Telecommunication 5. Telecommunications H04 Elektrische H04 Eelctric H04 Technique de la Nachrichtentechnik mit communication with communication elec- Ausnahmetechnique von the exception of H04N: trique, a l'exception H04N: Bildubertra pictorial communica- de H04N: transmission gung, z. B. Fernsehen tion, eg television d'images, p.ex. television Zur Information: For Information: Pour information: US-Klassen, unter US classes covering classes US couvrant die die entsprechenden corresponding les objets Gegenstande fallen subject-matter correspondents 370 Multiplexverkehr 370 Multiplex 370 Communications 375 Impuls-oder communications multiplex Digitalverkehr 375 Pulseor digital 375 Communications 379 Fernsprechverkehr communications numeriques ou a 380 Krytographie 379 Telephonic impulsions 381 Elektrische Systeme communication 379 Communication und Gerate fur die 380 Cryptography telephonique Audiosignalverabeitung 381 Electrical audio 380 Cryptographie 455 Telekommunikation signal processing 381 Dispositifs et systems and devices systemes de traitement 455 Telecommunications de signaux audio electriques 455 Telecommunications Erganzende Remarques Erlauterungen Notes Complementaires 6. Fur Anmeldungen, 6. The EPO is no longer 6. Pour les demandes die die in Absatz 1 the competent authority qui remplissent les genannten Voraussetz- within the meaning of conditions enoncees au ungen erfullen, ist Article 16(3)(b)1 and point 1, l'OEB n'est das EPA nicht mehr die Article 32(3)2 PCT for plus l'administration zustandige internation- applications meeting internationale ale Behorde im Sinne the criteria defined competente au sens de von Artikel 16(3)b)1 in paragraph 1. l'article 16(3)b)1 et und Artikel 32(3)2 PCT. de l'article 32(3)2 PCT. 7. Unter Absatz 1 7. Paragraph 1 also 7. Tombent egatement fallen auch Anmel- applies to applications sous le regime du point dungen, die statt beim filed with the IB 1, les demandes qui, au USPTO beim IB von rather than the USPTO lieu d'etre deposees mehreren Anmeldern by two or more aupres de l'USPTO sont eingereicht werden, applicants, deposees aupres du BI wenn par plusieurs deposants, dont: - mindestens - at least one of whom - l'un au moins est ein Anmelder is a national or ressortissant des Staatsangehoriger resident of the USA, Etats-Unis ou a son der USA ist oder dort and siege ou domicile aux seinen Sitz oder Etats-Unis; Wohnsitz hat und - kein Anmelder - none of whom are - aucun n'est ressor- Staatsangehoriger nationals or residents tissant d'un Etat eines EPU-Vertrags- of an EPC contracting partie a la CBE ou n'a staats ist oder dort state. son siege ou domicile seinen Sitz oder dans un de ces Etats. Wohnsitz hat. 8. Die Zustandigkeit 8. It is not possible 8. La competence de des EPA kann auch nicht to reassign competence l'OEB ne peut pas non dadurch wiederher- to the EPO by changing plus etre retablie par gestellt werden, daB the applicant after un changement de nach Einreichung der the application has deposant apres le depot Anmeldung beim USPTO been filed with the de la demande aupres de oder IB ein Wechsel des USPTO or the IB. l'USPTO ou du BI. Anmelders stattfindet. 9. Die Beschrankungs- 9. The limitation 9. Les criteres de kriterien in Absatz criteria in paragraph limitation enonces au 1 b) gelten fur alle 1(b) apply to all point 1b) s'appliquent Antrage auf interna- demands for interna- a toutes les demandes tionale vorlaufige tional preliminary d'examem preliminaire Prufung,die am oder examination received international recues nach dem 1. Marz 2002 at the EPO on or after par l'OEB a partir beim EPA eingehen 2, 1 March 2002 2, which du 1st mars 2002 2: erfassen also auch means they are also ils s'appliquent dons Anmeldungen, die vor applicable to applica- aussi aux demandes de dem 1. Marz 2002 tions filed before 1 brevet deposees avant eingereicht worden March 2002 for which le 1st mars 2002 et sind und fur die das the EPO was still the pour lesquelles l'OEB EPA noch zustandige competent International etait encore internationale Searching Authority. l'administration Recherchenbehorde war. competente chargee de la recherche internationale. 1 Des Anmaldeant 1 The receiving Office 1 L'Office recepteur streicht von Amts wegen deletes the indication supprime d'office die Angabe jeder unzus- of any non-competant l'indication de tandugan Internation- International Searching toute administration alen Recherchambehorde Authority ex officio chargee de la recherche (Richtilien fur das (Receiving Office internationale qui Anmeldeamt, Nr. 115, Guidelines, No. 115, n'est pas competente PCT-Blatt-IV, 29 von PCT Gazette-IV, 29 of (Directives a l'usage 17, September 1998). 17 September 1998). des offices recepteurs, no 115, Gazette du PCT-IV, 29 du 17 septembre 1998). 2 Auf bei dar 2 Demands for interna- 2 La regle 59.3 PCT unzustandigen Behorte tional preliminary c'applique aux demandes singereichte Antrage examination submitted d'examen preliminaire suf internationale to a non-competent international presentees vorlaufige Prufung authority are subject supres d'une findet to